(You can choose or or both)

Saturday, February 12, 2011

Fantasy ... Imagination


Je me rappelle dans ma jeunesse (il y a fort fort longtemps...) avoir entendu des discussions entre 'grands' - des chrétiens 'sincères' qui débattaient la valeur du monde fantastique. Selon certains, on ne devait pas donner des livres du genre fantastique, féerique, magique à ses enfants - non pas parce que cela pourrait les conduire à l'occultisme, mais parce que cela concernait le non-réel - donc quelque chose qui n'était pas crée par Dieu.

Quelque chose comme ça... Je crois qu'il y avait une exception pour la simple fiction 'réaliste', mais je n'en suis pas sûr.

Aujourd'hui, ce genre de raisonnement "'logique' mais complètement dépourvu de bon sens" fait sonner l'alerte générale chez moi. Gare au gourou!

Mais dernièrement j'ai repensé à cette histoire, parce que je me suis rendu compte que cultiver l'imagination chez nos enfants est une nécessité si nous voulons inculquer le régle d'or. Car j'ai observé que les personnes qui sont les moins aptes à "faire aux autres commes ils aimeraient qu'on leur fasse" sont ceux qui n'arrive pas à se "mettre à la place de l'autre", ils n'arrivent pas à se projeter dans une autre réalité que la leur.

Et ils sont dépourvues d'imagination.

Alors n'ayez pas peur des Ents, ils sont gentils!
I have vague recollections, from way back when, of listening in on 'grown up' discussions between Christians who were debating the merits (or otherwise) of fantasy and fiction. Some of them maintained that you shouldn't give fantasy books to your children to read - not because they risked falling into occultism, but because fantasy concerns non-real worlds, not the world that God created for us to live in.

I think there was an exception for 'normal' fiction, but I'm not sure.

Nowadays that kind of "'logical' but completely devoid of common sense" thinking sets off my air-raid sirens.

I was reminded of these discussions recently because I realised that it is essential to cultivate our children's imaginations if we want to teach them the Golden Rule. I've observed over time that the people who are the worse at "doing unto others as they'd like to have them done to" are those who can't "put themselves in another's shoes": they can't project themselves onto someone else's reality.

Empathy is impossible without imagination.

So, don't fear the Ents, they're here to help!

2 comments yet :

Viv Simkins said...

Lots of thoughts on this one.
First, do such 'rules' change with the times. A novel written in Victorian times warned the heroine against reading novels, because frothy fiction of the Mills and Boon type disposes females especially to an unreal view of romantic love. More recently, folks have been wary of cinema.
Secondly, empathy and imagination are really good, but does one need fantasy for that? Why not historical novels or biographies set in other countries?
Thirdly, maybe a mixed diet is best. I worry about adults who only read fantasy.

Benjol said...

Lots of things change with the times, including what's deemed appropriate or not.

I guess you could get by on historical novels and different styles of 'otherness'.

And yes, a mixed diet of 'good' quality reading is the best. That is probably subjective too...